If ARC Raiders works for you because a squad has to move carefully, recover from a bad plan, and get out together, the next game does not need to copy every system. The useful question is what you want less of. For many players, it is not danger or teamwork; it is the feeling that an unknown opponent can turn an otherwise good night into a loss.
Start with Deep Rock Galactic if that is your problem. It keeps the part where a team has jobs, a route can collapse, and the exit matters, but it puts the pressure in caves, swarms, and bad decisions instead of another squad's aim. The tradeoff is important: it is friendlier and more mission-shaped than ARC Raiders, so it will not replace every piece of scavenging tension.
The rest of this guide branches from there. Pick HELLDIVERS 2 when you want a louder team firefight, Risk of Rain 2 when escalating builds are the hook, The Forever Winter when harsh scavenging is still essential, or Hunt: Showdown 1896 only if you have decided that human opponents are still part of the fun.
Lowest PvP heat
Big squad firefights
Closest harsh scavenging
Choose the source of pressure first. Extraction shooters can mean a tense exit, a squad mission, a build run, or a fight with other players—and those are not interchangeable.
Start with the pressure you want to keep
You do not need a one-for-one ARC Raiders replacement. You need a co-op shooter whose failure state still sounds fun after a rough run. Decide whether you want the team to fear the environment, the clock, a fragile build, or another human squad before buying on the broad extraction-shooter label.
| If your group wants... | Start with | What you give up |
|---|---|---|
| A pure co-op mission where everyone has a job | Deep Rock Galactic | Less persistent loot-risk and less surface-world tension |
| Evacuation pressure with spectacular shared firepower | HELLDIVERS 2 | More combat spectacle, less scavenging |
| Short runs where the build becomes the story | Risk of Rain 2 | Roguelite resets instead of extraction persistence |
| Tactical scavenging beneath overwhelming machines | The Forever Winter | A harsher, less relaxed first step |
| Real extraction stakes with monsters and rival hunters | Hunt: Showdown 1896 | The PvP stress you may be trying to leave |
That is why the first pick is not simply the game with the closest genre tag. For a group already tired of competitive friction, the better test is whether a mistake creates a story for the team or an argument about a player they never saw.
For zero-PvP squads: Deep Rock Galactic or HELLDIVERS 2
Choose this lane when you want communication and chaotic exits without having to monitor another squad's skill level or schedule. Deep Rock Galactic is the better first pick when the team wants a shared problem to solve. HELLDIVERS 2 is the better pick when the group wants an immediate, noisy mission night.
Deep Rock is the more deliberate recommendation because its missions make each person useful: someone lights the route, someone keeps the swarm off the team, and someone remembers that a tunnel is not a safe shortcut. Its extraction is an escape from a run the group created together, not a showdown with strangers.
Deep Rock Galactic
Recommendation
- Best for
- Groups that want the relief of a successful exit without any enemy-player pressure.
- Why it fits
- It is a 1–4-player co-op FPS built around dangerous, destructible cave missions, alien swarms, and a team that has to mine and survive together. The structure gives everyone a reason to communicate.
- Skip if
- You need scavenged gear and a persistent extraction loop to be the main source of tension.
Deep Rock is not the closest tonal match, and that is useful. It preserves the cooperative tension while letting a group learn whether it actually misses extraction stakes or simply misses having a clear shared job.
HELLDIVERS 2
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want a fast third-person squad shooter and an evacuation that can turn into a disaster together.
- Why it fits
- HELLDIVERS 2 leans into hostile-planet firefights, friendly chaos, and a group that has to keep moving under pressure. It is the right branch when the team wants action first and careful scavenging second.
- Skip if
- You want quieter route planning, loot recovery, or a tense search-and-escape rhythm.
Pick HELLDIVERS 2 when the group is saying “give us a mission tonight,” not “give us a place to poke around carefully.” Its best stories arrive when the plan becomes loud, while Deep Rock's usually arrive when the cave makes the plan impossible.
For build-driven runs: Risk of Rain 2
Choose Risk of Rain 2 when ARC Raiders' gear decisions interest you more than the extraction setting itself. It is a co-op shooter where each run can become wildly different as items stack, which means a bad early choice can become a funny recovery instead of a permanent loss.
Risk of Rain 2
Recommendation
- Best for
- Friends who want fast co-op runs, escalating item builds, and a reason to start another attempt immediately.
- Why it fits
- Risk of Rain 2 turns the build into the drama: combine loot in surprising ways, learn a survivor, and decide when the team is strong enough to move on. It offers pressure without making a rival squad the threat.
- Skip if
- Your favorite part is slow scavenging, careful positioning, and carrying a haul home.
This is the clearest genre shift on the list. It is not an extraction shooter in the same sense as ARC Raiders, and the reset is the point. Choose it when the group wants intensity and replayability more than a persistent loot-risk loop.
For harsh scavenging: The Forever Winter
Choose this lane when you want the word “extraction” to still carry weight, but you would rather face a brutal world than turn every run into a competitive match. The Forever Winter is the closest fit here for players who want tactical movement and scavenging pressure to remain central.
The Forever Winter
Recommendation
- Best for
- A squad that wants tactical scavenging under frightening world pressure, not a relaxed co-op campaign.
- Why it fits
- Its Steam description puts you and a squad in a tactical shooter where you loot the dead beneath enormous war machines. That makes danger and recovery feel like the point rather than a short bridge to the next gunfight.
- Skip if
- Your group wants the most welcoming first night or prefers bright, high-clarity co-op action.
Treat this as the commitment pick. The attraction is not that it smooths out the rough edges; it is that it gives a team a reason to move carefully and leave with something before the larger conflict notices them.
The wrong default: Hunt: Showdown 1896
Hunt is a real extraction shooter with monsters, bounties, and exits that matter. It belongs in the conversation, but it is the wrong first answer for a reader whose problem is PvP burnout. The game deliberately puts ruthless opponents back in the run, so the tension comes from another team hearing the same shot you did.
Hunt: Showdown 1896
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who still want high-stakes extraction, but want monsters and bounty hunting mixed into the PvP.
- Why it fits
- Hunt makes the exit consequential: track a bounty in a corrupted setting, survive the monsters, and deal with rival hunters who can take the reward. It is tense for exactly the reason a PvP-tired group may want a break.
- Skip if
- The goal is to keep co-op coordination while removing the feeling that an unseen human team controls the night.
If your group says it wants “an extraction shooter,” ask one more question: would losing a good run to another team feel exciting or exhausting? If the answer is exhausting, do not buy Hunt because it is closest to the label. Start with Deep Rock or The Forever Winter instead.
Pick your next squad night
Use this final split when the group has stopped arguing about genre names and started naming the pressure it actually wants. The rows below are deliberately narrow. A clean choice beats a giant list that sends the group into the same kind of game it was trying to leave.
The safest first click for jobs, swarms, caves, and memorable exits without PvP.
Choose it for fast third-person fights and an evacuation that can go wrong together.
Best when repeatable runs and item combinations matter more than persistent extraction stakes.
The heavier option for a squad that wants danger to come from the world, not a ranked lobby.
Pick it only when rival hunters make the story better rather than draining the group.
Start with the kind of pressure your group enjoys, then accept the tradeoff honestly.
If you are still undecided, click Deep Rock Galactic first. It is the quickest honest test of whether your group wants less PvP or simply wants a different kind of pressure after ARC Raiders.
Play queue
Play these next
See game details, similar picks, and store options.
