Subnautica is hard to replace because it is not just a survival crafting game. The good part is the feeling that every deeper trip might reveal a new biome, a new threat, or a quiet answer to why this planet feels wrong.
If you want another game like Subnautica, start with the feeling you miss. Pick Subnautica 2 if you want the closest new ocean and do not mind Early Access. Pick Outer Wilds if the mystery mattered most. Pick The Planet Crafter if you want survival, crafting, and base progress without a pure chore loop. Pick Subnautica: Below Zero if you want a finished solo continuation.
The trap is buying the nearest survival sandbox and hoping the awe shows up. Many excellent survival games give you hunger, trees, raids, and storage boxes. Fewer give you that lonely push to go one layer deeper.
Closest new ocean
Mystery first
Survival-building progress
Finished solo follow-up
Choose by the reason you still think about Subnautica, not by the broad survival-crafting label.
The shared itch
Subnautica works because survival systems give exploration a cost. Oxygen, food, depth, darkness, and inventory space matter because they force a decision: turn back safe, or push deeper because the next signal might explain the world.
That is why the best follow-up depends on which part stayed with you. Some players want the alien mystery. Some want a base that slowly earns better trips. Some want water anxiety. Some want a calmer version of the loop where building is satisfying instead of stressful.
| If you miss... | Start with | What you give up |
|---|---|---|
| The closest new alien ocean | Subnautica 2 | A finished campaign and solo-only design |
| Handcrafted mystery and knowledge-based progress | Outer Wilds | Survival crafting, bases, and resource tiers |
| Survival crafting with visible world change | The Planet Crafter | Ocean dread and creature horror |
| A finished solo alien-ocean story | Subnautica: Below Zero | Some of the first game's silence and isolation |
| A moving home base on water | Raft | A tighter mystery and lonely pacing |
| Huge exploration and base building | No Man's Sky | A focused authored world |
| Cozy planet logistics | ASTRONEER | Real fear and survival pressure |
If you want a new underwater sequel
Start here if you mainly want familiar underwater survival, crafted tools, custom bases, and another alien mystery. Subnautica 2 is the direct mechanics-first option, but the tradeoff is substantial: it is in Early Access and supports optional four-player co-op. You can play alone, but this is not a finished, solo-only campaign.
Subnautica 2
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want the newest alien ocean and the closest mechanics-first follow-up.
- Why it fits
- Subnautica 2 keeps underwater survival, crafted tools, custom bases, and a new world's hidden mysteries while adding optional four-player co-op.
- Skip if
- You want a finished campaign or a game designed only for solo play; it is currently in Early Access.
Start with Subnautica 2 when more underwater survival is enough. Players who miss the original's isolation or want a complete story today should compare it with the finished Below Zero before buying.
If mystery mattered more than crafting
Choose this lane if Subnautica was really about scanning ruins, reading the planet, and realizing the map had rules you did not understand yet. These picks are best when curiosity matters more than chopping another stack of materials.
Outer Wilds
Recommendation
- Best for
- Subnautica players who want the mystery, not the crafting chores.
- Why it fits
- Outer Wilds replaces depth modules and blueprints with knowledge. You explore strange places, learn how they work, and use that understanding to reach answers you could technically reach from the start.
- Skip if
- You need base building, resource storage, crafting tiers, or a long survival campaign.
Outer Wilds is the cleanest answer for players who remember Subnautica as a mystery game with danger attached. It does not scratch the base-building itch, but it gives you the same pleasure of understanding a strange place piece by piece.
Subnautica: Below Zero
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want another alien ocean before changing genres.
- Why it fits
- Below Zero keeps the vehicles, scanning, cold water, base modules, and alien ecology, but it is more character-led and more directed than the original.
- Skip if
- The silence, loneliness, and huge unknown of the first game were the whole point.
Subnautica: Below Zero is the safest recommendation and the easiest one to misunderstand. It is not a bad next click. It is just less lonely, which matters if the first game worked because nobody was there to soften the ocean.
Breathedge
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want survival in a strange place but can tolerate a louder tone.
- Why it fits
- Breathedge has oxygen management, scavenging, space-wreck exploration, crafted tools, and authored progression, so the structure is closer to Subnautica than many forest survival games.
- Skip if
- Comedy bits would ruin the lonely, uncanny mood you want.
Breathedge belongs as a caveat pick. The survival-exploration shape fits, but the jokes are not a small detail. If Subnautica's quiet dread was the reason you stayed, watch footage before buying.
If you want survival pressure with less sandbox drift
If you liked bases, upgrades, and risk but want the loop to keep pointing somewhere, start with games where building visibly changes what you can reach.
Subnautica's closest matches that are survival games
Match strength key:80+65+50+<5080 of the 100 closest matches to Subnautica are survival games.
Subnautica: Below ZeroShares Open World Survival Craft · Underwater · Exploration90% · 108k positive reviews−10%$26.9986%Excellent match
Subnautica 2Shares Underwater · Open World · Exploration , adds Co-op91% · 128k positive reviews$29.9985%Excellent match
Stranded DeepShares Open World Survival Craft · Underwater · Exploration , adds Realistic74% · 48k positive reviews−10%$17.9975%Strong match
Murky DiversShares Underwater · Exploration · First-Person , adds Funny87% · 3k positive reviews−10%$8.0978%Strong match
Under A New SunShares Open World Survival Craft · Underwater · Exploration , adds Realistic77% · 301 positive reviews$17.9975%Strong match
SubterrorShares Underwater · First-Person · Survival Horror , adds Online Co-Op91% · 380 positive reviews$7.9977%Strong match
NarcosisShares Underwater · First-Person · Survival Horror , adds Psychological Horror76% · 1k positive reviews−78%$3.2371%Strong match
SunkenlandShares Open World Survival Craft · Underwater · Exploration , adds Co-op80% · 24k positive reviews−20%$15.9977%Strong match
Median match strength inside this slice is 67%, against 67% across all 100 matches. The strongest overall matches all are survival games, so the filter costs nothing here.
The Planet Crafter
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want crafting, bases, and exploration with a clear purpose.
- Why it fits
- You start on a dead planet and gradually terraform it. That visible transformation gives the resource loop a reason, so building feels like discovery support instead of spreadsheet maintenance.
- Skip if
- You want predators, ocean dread, or a darker story.
The Planet Crafter is the survival-building pick here because its resource loop visibly changes the planet instead of only expanding storage. It is gentler than Subnautica, but gathering and building still lets you see more and reach farther.
Forever Skies
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want a vehicle-home, ruined-world mystery, and survival tech.
- Why it fits
- Forever Skies moves the base fantasy into an airship. You repair, expand, scavenge, and descend into danger, which gives exploration a home-base rhythm without copying the ocean.
- Skip if
- You only want proven, finished-feeling classics with huge review pools.
Forever Skies earns its spot through the mobile shelter, environmental danger, and ruined-world pull. Its Steam audience is much smaller than Subnautica, Raft, or No Man's Sky, so watch recent footage before treating it as a sure thing.
Grounded
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want a guided survival adventure, especially with friends.
- Why it fits
- Grounded gives you base building, gear, dangerous zones, creature threats, and a readable campaign structure. It is survival with momentum, not a blank server.
- Skip if
- You want solitude, ocean scale, or an alien planet mood.
Grounded is the better pick when you want survival systems but need more authored direction. It is brighter and more social than Subnautica, so it belongs below the mystery-first and planet-building choices for solo isolation.
If you want ocean anxiety
Go here if the water itself was the draw: open sea, limited safety, something below you, and a base or vehicle that feels fragile. These picks share the water, but only some keep the dread.
Raft
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want ocean survival, co-op, and a floating home.
- Why it fits
- Raft keeps you on the water, makes the base itself the journey, and gives your group a clear loop: collect, build, sail, dive, repeat.
- Skip if
- You want quiet alien discovery more than crafting, collection, and co-op upkeep.
Raft is a good game and a risky default. It answers "water survival" better than "Subnautica mystery." If your favorite memories are the Cyclops, deep biomes, and the fear of descending, start with Subnautica 2 or Below Zero before Raft.
Stranded Deep
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want island survival and ocean danger.
- Why it fits
- Stranded Deep gives you rafts, sharks, islands, crafting, hunger, thirst, and the practical stress of staying alive in open water.
- Skip if
- You are trying to avoid pure sandbox chores.
Stranded Deep is here because the ocean fit is real. It is also exactly the kind of recommendation to downrank for this target player: the loop is more survival-craft task work than alien discovery.
Subnautica: Below Zero
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want the safest underwater continuation.
- Why it fits
- Below Zero keeps the sea bases, cold-water pressure, scanning, creatures, and environmental progression close to the original formula.
- Skip if
- You would rather protect your memory of Subnautica than play a smaller, more spoken sequel.
If you are searching for games similar to Subnautica because you simply want another underwater alien world, Below Zero should be above most genre experiments. Just go in expecting a different emotional temperature.
If you want cozier base building
Choose this lane if Subnautica's base became your safe place and you want more exploration without constant dread. The best first pick depends on whether you want huge scale, playful logistics, or terraforming progress.
If the base matters more than the ocean, the games like Minecraft guide is the better next stop.
No Man's Sky
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want vast exploration, scanning, ships, and bases.
- Why it fits
- No Man's Sky gives you planets, creatures, vehicles, base building, underwater zones, and long-term discovery. It is enormous, flexible, and much less claustrophobic.
- Skip if
- You want one tight handcrafted mystery instead of a galaxy-sized sandbox.
No Man's Sky is the scale pick. It can absorb hundreds of hours, but that is also the warning. If you need Subnautica's directed sense that the planet has one secret, No Man's Sky can feel too wide.
ASTRONEER
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want cheerful planetary exploration and base logistics.
- Why it fits
- ASTRONEER keeps the oxygen tether, strange planets, vehicles, resource loops, and base expansion, but lowers the fear and makes the whole thing friendlier.
- Skip if
- You need danger, horror, or a strong story pull.
ASTRONEER is for the player who wants the loop without the dread. It is still about pushing farther from safety, but the emotional pitch is curiosity and tinkering rather than fear.
The Planet Crafter
Recommendation
- Best for
- Players who want a home base that changes the planet around it.
- Why it fits
- Its best trick is making your machines, rooms, and upgrades visibly alter the world, so the base is not just storage. It is the engine of the whole campaign.
- Skip if
- You need creatures, combat danger, or deep-sea atmosphere.
The reason The Planet Crafter appears twice is simple: it is the rare pick that can serve both survival builders and cozy base players. Raise or lower it depending on how much threat you need.
The wrong default: do not start with the broad survival list
If you search for survival games like Subnautica, you will quickly land in a much bigger genre: forests, zombies, raids, PvP servers, harsh hunger systems, and endless base optimization. Some of those games are excellent. They are not automatically good Subnautica replacements.
The Long Dark is tense and lonely, but it gives you weather, cold, wolves, and hard survival judgment rather than alien ecology or base-building discovery.
Green Hell has a strong survival reputation too, but it pushes deeper into bodily survival and punishment. That is useful if you want the hard-sim edge. It is the wrong first click if you are trying to avoid pure survival chores.
Use broad survival-crafting lists after you know you want the genre. For a Subnautica hangover, choose the missing feeling first.
Where to go next
For the full recommendation graph, use the Subnautica page. This guide is for deciding which part of Subnautica you want back first. For a direct continuation, compare Early Access Subnautica 2 with the finished Subnautica: Below Zero.
For mystery, go to Outer Wilds. For survival-building progress, go to The Planet Crafter. For ocean co-op survival, go to Raft. For huge exploration and bases, go to No Man's Sky.
FAQ
Which Subnautica-like game should I buy first?
There is no single replacement. Choose Subnautica 2 for a new alien ocean if Early Access is acceptable, Outer Wilds for mystery, The Planet Crafter for survival-building progress, or Subnautica: Below Zero for a finished solo continuation.
Are there games similar to Subnautica with base building?
Yes. Start with The Planet Crafter, No Man's Sky, ASTRONEER, or Raft. Pick The Planet Crafter if you want the base to push a campaign forward instead of becoming a storage project.
What should I play if I want underwater games like Subnautica?
Play Subnautica 2 first if Early Access and optional co-op suit you. Choose Subnautica: Below Zero instead if you want a finished solo game. Try Raft if you want ocean survival and a floating base, or Stranded Deep if island survival sounds good and you do not mind more chore-heavy crafting.
Is Raft the closest game to Subnautica?
Raft is close on water survival, not on lonely alien mystery. It is a better pick for co-op collection, floating-base expansion, and ocean travel than for the "what is down there?" feeling.
- Choose Subnautica 2 if you want the closest new ocean and accept Early Access.
- Choose Outer Wilds if the best part of Subnautica was uncovering a strange world.
- Choose The Planet Crafter if you want crafting, bases, and progress that changes the map.
- Choose Subnautica: Below Zero if you want a finished solo underwater follow-up.
- Choose Raft if ocean co-op and a floating base matter more than mystery.
- Choose No Man's Sky if you want huge exploration and do not need a tight story.
- Choose ASTRONEER if you want the safer, cozier version of oxygen, planets, and base logistics.
Pick by the feeling you want back, not by the longest survival feature list.
If you are buying today and want minimum risk, choose Below Zero for finished Subnautica or Outer Wilds for mystery. Choose Subnautica 2 only when Early Access is an acceptable part of the purchase.
Play queue
Play these next
See game details, similar picks, and store options.
