70%Strong matchDarkness Within 1: In Pursuit of Loath Nolder
74%53974% positive reviews, Mostly Positive across 539 reviews·Horror · Lovecraftian
—






A psychological indie horror game. While seeking to find the truth about the disappearances in the forest you find a lot more than you expected.
Cave of Illusions surrounds a series of events in Looninville, New Hampshire, where an eight-year-old girl vanishes abruptly. Her name was Addie Baker, and strangely enough, she is not the first to disappear in Looninville. For Lesley Jacobson, now a private phenomenon investigator, Addie Baker was her best friend and neighbor growing up. Twenty-eight-years later, Lesley is still haunted by the night Addie disappeared, as she was the only one to witness it, or was she?
Deciding to combine her personal and professional life, Lesley returns to Looninville to close the mystery and move forward in life with her daughter. Lacking to find any concrete evidence or input from the skittish locals, Lesley returns to the one place that appears to be at the center of these strange occurrences, a cave. The uneasy problem with this, is that Lesley does not remember there ever being a cave at all.
Cave of Illusions is a psychological, atmospheric horror game that will have you questioning every step taken as the reality around you will begin to shift. Things are not always as they seem, even when witnessed with the naked eye, and one must pursue the constant battle of the mind with remembering what you think you know and understanding what you actually know. How long can one wear the mask of sanity?
Steam data © 2026 Valve Corporation. Trademarks are property of their respective owners.
All matches
Finding similar games…
Darkness Within 1: In Pursuit of Loath NolderShares Psychological Horror · Puzzle · First-Person , adds Lovecraftian74% · 539 positive reviews70%Strong match—
9 Childs StreetShares Psychological Horror · First-Person · Supernatural , adds Dark91% · 645 positive reviews64%Good match—
Locked UpShares Psychological Horror · Surreal · First-Person , adds Walking Simulator77% · 1k positive reviews65%Strong match—
Children of SilentownShares Psychological Horror · Puzzle · Surreal , adds Point & Click87% · 905 positive reviews68%Strong match—
VivietteShares Psychological Horror · Puzzle · Multiple Endings , adds Pixel Graphics88% · 460 positive reviews69%Strong match—
InflictionShares Psychological Horror · Surreal · First-Person , adds Walking Simulator82% · 764 positive reviews68%Strong match—All matches
The best games like Cave of Illusions are Darkness Within 1: In Pursuit of Loath Nolder, 9 Childs Street, Locked Up, Children of Silentown, and Viviette.
Match on: filter matches for Cave of Illusions by tag
Filters all matches
65%+Strong matches
50%+Good matches