69%Strong matchThe Caribbean Sail
94%48094% positive reviews, Very Positive across 480 reviews·Pirates · Sailing
—Arrr! Solve the riddles of an old captain Flint and find the pirate treasure!
Become the Terror of the Caribbean as you tease your brain—and the tides—in this mind-blowing pirate puzzler! Explore six different islands on your search for Captain Flint’s lost treasures! With more than 120 unique puzzles to solve, you’ll be singing along to jolly pirate melodies and sailing through hours of captivating gameplay! Go ahead, hoist the Jolly Roger! Fair winds to ye, sea dog!
- 120 unique puzzles to solve
- 4+ hours of gameplay
- Six different islands to explore
Steam data © 2026 Valve Corporation. Trademarks are property of their respective owners.
All matches
Finding similar games…
Puzzle DimensionShares Puzzle , adds Logic90% · 445 positive reviews60%Good match—
The Caribbean SailShares Casual · Adventure , adds Pirates94% · 480 positive reviews69%Strong match—
Jolly RoverShares Puzzle , adds Point & Click89% · 233 positive reviews61%Good match—
Islands of InsightShares Puzzle , adds Puzzle Platformer75% · 2k positive reviews66%Strong match—
Sid Meier's Pirates!Shares Adventure , adds Pirates95% · 6k positive reviews66%Strong match—
Hidden Object Bundle 4 in 1Shares Casual · Adventure , adds Hidden Object93% · 334 positive reviews54%Good match—All matches
The best games like Fill and Cross Pirate Riddles are Puzzle Dimension, The Caribbean Sail, Jolly Rover, Islands of Insight, and Sid Meier's Pirates!.
Match on: filter matches for Fill and Cross Pirate Riddles by tag
Filters all matches
65%+Strong matches
50%+Good matches