62%Good matchThe Witch of Fern Island
69%92569% positive reviews, Mixed across 925 reviews·2024·Female Protagonist · Life Sim
—




Enter the world of Mutter Island as Sylvie, a newfound witch with the ability to grow magical Critters. Restore the island, welcome the unwelcome, and uncover the mystery of Sylvie's past!

Sylvie’s story begins as a newfound witch that has been chased out of her hometown for her abilities. When she arrives on Mutter Island she discovers she is capable of growing magical Critter Crops that will aid her in restoring the island to its former glory. Uncover the secrets of the island by growing magical critters in this isometric role-playing/management game!

Farm, Noodle, Mine, Gather, and Explore the island in order to level up your abilities and uncover more of the mysteries of Mutter Island. Gather resources to help restore Mur Mur Town and use your critters to help you traverse the wild areas of the island.




Sylvie isn't the only one looking for refuge. Many others will show up on Mutter Island seeking to start a new life!

Steam data © 2026 Valve Corporation. Trademarks are property of their respective owners.
All matches
Finding similar games…
The Witch of Fern IslandShares Farming Sim · Immersive Sim · Open World , adds Female Protagonist69% · 925 positive reviews62%Good match—
Critter CoveShares Farming Sim · Colorful · Family Friendly , adds Stylized95% · 2k positive reviews62%Good match—
Harvest IslandShares Cozy · Farming Sim · Exploration , adds Dark82% · 214 positive reviews61%Good match—
Little Witch in the WoodsShares Farming Sim · Creature Collector · Immersive Sim , adds Pixel Graphics89% · 13k positive reviews60%Good match—
Research StoryShares Cozy · Farming Sim · Creature Collector , adds Life Sim95% · 251 positive reviews60%Good match—
Cozy IslandShares Cozy · Farming Sim · Open World , adds Life Sim92% · 3k positive reviews60%Good match—All matches
The best games like Critter Crops are The Witch of Fern Island, Critter Cove, Harvest Island, Little Witch in the Woods, and Research Story.
Want picks that fit how you play? Ask GamesLike in ChatGPT
Match on: filter matches for Critter Crops by tag