56%Good matchSucker for Love: Date to Die For
95%1k95% positive reviews, Overwhelmingly Positive across 1k reviews·2024·Dating Sim · Visual Novel
—




Everyone's heard of Mothman– the moth creature that haunts the outskirts of Point Pleasant, West Virginia– but no one's heard of it like this! In some random idyllic Midwestern town, you meet Artemis (aka Mothman) at your favorite coffee shop and begin an agonizingly slow burn romance with them.
Everyone's heard of Mothman– the big, scary, feathery moth creature that haunts around the outskirts of Point Pleasant, West Virginia– but no one's ever heard of it like this! In some random idyllic Midwestern town, you meet Artemis (aka Mothman) at your favorite coffee shop and begin an agonizingly slow burn romance with them.


Cryptid Coffeehouse is a very casual, slice-of-life game about living in the American Midwest, meeting new people, and developing feelings for someone. It's a game about relationships and the importance of consent, permission, and respect in those relationships, especially relationships that are between stages. And, as corny as it sounds, it's a game about being yourself.
Content warnings: swearing, mentions of recreational alcohol & marijuana consumption, sexual tension, and a lot of kissing ;)
Steam data © 2026 Valve Corporation. Trademarks are property of their respective owners.
All matches
Finding similar games…
Sucker for Love: Date to Die ForShares Dating Sim · LGBTQ+ · Romance , adds Anime95% · 1k positive reviews56%Good match—
Coffee Talk Episode 2: Hibiscus & ButterflyShares LGBTQ+ · Visual Novel · Interactive Fiction , adds 4215296% · 3k positive reviews56%Good match—
Mythic Love: Iberian LegendsShares Dating Sim · LGBTQ+ · Romance , adds Mythology93% · 273 positive reviews55%Good match—
Tavern Talk - A Cozy Visual NovelShares LGBTQ+ · Visual Novel · Interactive Fiction , adds Cozy89% · 2k positive reviews54%Good match—
Bewitching SinnersShares Dating Sim · LGBTQ+ · Romance , adds Comic Book96% · 371 positive reviews54%Good match—
Sucker for LoveShares Dating Sim · Romance · Visual Novel , adds Anime98% · 3k positive reviews54%Good match—All matches
The best games like Cryptid Coffeehouse are Sucker for Love: Date to Die For, Coffee Talk Episode 2: Hibiscus & Butterfly, Mythic Love: Iberian Legends, Tavern Talk - A Cozy Visual Novel, and Bewitching Sinners.
Want picks that fit how you play? Ask GamesLike in ChatGPT
Match on: filter matches for Cryptid Coffeehouse by tag