66%Strong matchThe Story of Henry Bishop
83%49383% positive reviews, Very Positive across 493 reviews·Horror · Violent
—Two friends investigate the disappearance of people and encounter unexplained phenomena.

This game is an independent work inspired by American urban legends and is not affiliated with any TV series, movies, or copyrighted fictional universes. All characters, events and coincidences that may occur during the game are purely coincidental and have no relation to real people, places or events. Any coincidences with real situations, personalities or historical facts are purely coincidental. The content and plot of the game are fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. The developers are not responsible for possible misinterpretations or unintended consequences of game events. Play at your own discretion and exercise good judgment in all things. The main character, Sim, has a wife who goes missing. During the investigation, he learns that she is in the hands of a powerful demon who is blackmailing our protagonist in every way possible. He enlists the help of his best friend Dan, who also has a personal grudge against the demon.

They will have to put a lot of effort to get out of this difficult situation. When they start actively searching for the main suspect, the danger on their way grows to unbelievable proportions. The police and the hunters of unclean powers think that the same man is behind all these crimes...
.Along the way, we will encounter all kinds and horrible monsters that we will have to fight.

.Evil awaits them in every home, every village, and every forest.
Steam data © 2026 Valve Corporation. Trademarks are property of their respective owners.
All matches
Finding similar games…
The Story of Henry BishopShares Shooter · Zombies · Survival , adds Survival Horror83% · 493 positive reviews66%Strong match—
The Beast InsideShares Realistic · Survival · Psychological Horror , adds First-Person84% · 10k positive reviews66%Strong match—
MetaPhysicalShares Supernatural · Shooter · Psychological Horror , adds Detective84% · 286 positive reviews65%Strong match—
Don't Be AfraidShares Realistic · Survival · Psychological Horror , adds First-Person82% · 720 positive reviews64%Good match—
Remothered: Tormented FathersShares Third Person · Psychological Horror , adds Female Protagonist75% · 2k positive reviews64%Good match—
Evil TonightShares Supernatural · Horror · Survival , adds Pixel Graphics88% · 456 positive reviews64%Good match—All matches
The best games like Unnatural: Benighted are The Story of Henry Bishop, The Beast Inside, MetaPhysical, Don't Be Afraid, and Remothered: Tormented Fathers.
Match on: filter matches for Unnatural: Benighted by tag