57%Good matchThe Painscreek Killings
91%6k91% positive reviews, Very Positive across 6k reviews·2017·Investigation · Mystery
—




Rebecca's search for her missing girlfriend, Leanna, takes her to the Hemisfair Health Clinic, where nothing is as it seems. Uncover secrets, face gripping encounters, and unravel a chilling mystery in this story-focused third-person experience.
When Rebecca loses contact with her girlfriend Leanna during a late-night call, fear drives her to investigate. She heads to the Hemisfair Health Clinic, where Leanna was last heard from, only to discover she’s vanished without a trace. As she digs deeper, she crosses paths with unsettling individuals whose actions raise more questions than answers. What begins as a desperate search for Leanna spirals into a harrowing journey to uncover the truth. Experience this gripping, story-driven third-person adventure where narrative takes center stage.

Investigate the Clinic During the Dead of Night: Embark on a tense late-night exploration of the Hemisfair Health Clinic to uncover the mystery behind Leanna’s disappearance.

Uncover secrets, and face tense encounters: Stay on your toes during high-stakes situations where your reactions can mean the difference between life and death.

Live the Story in San Antonio: Become part of the narrative as you explore San Antonio, TX, through the eyes of its characters and their challenges

Cinematic Storytelling: Engage with immersive cutscene narratives designed to pull you deeper into the story and connect you to the characters' journeys.

Checkpoint-Based Saving: The game automatically saves progress at key checkpoints, ensuring a smooth and immersive gameplay experience.
Steam data © 2026 Valve Corporation. Trademarks are property of their respective owners.
All matches
Finding similar games…
The Painscreek KillingsShares Mystery · Female Protagonist · Exploration , adds Puzzle91% · 6k positive reviews57%Good match—
SupernaturalShares Detective · Dark · Investigation , adds Crime63% · 1k positive reviews57%Good match—
UnheardShares Mystery · Exploration · Detective , adds Thriller96% · 29k positive reviews57%Good match—
The Almost GoneShares Mystery · Female Protagonist · Exploration , adds Puzzle81% · 954 positive reviews56%Good match—
HeartwormShares Mystery · Female Protagonist · Exploration , adds Survival Horror88% · 373 positive reviews56%Good match—
HomebodyShares Mystery · Exploration · Drama , adds Puzzle93% · 623 positive reviews56%Good match—All matches
The best games like Unforgivable are The Painscreek Killings, Supernatural, Unheard, The Almost Gone, and Heartworm.
Want picks that fit how you play? Ask GamesLike in ChatGPT
Match on: filter matches for Unforgivable by tag