57%Good matchThe Stalked
92%34192% positive reviews, Very Positive across 341 reviews·Horror · Atmospheric
—






What Happened to Lily? Is a real-time first-person horror game. Discover the secrets and spooky truths behind the mysterious event at Miller Farm.
Just outside the quiet town of Coffeyville, Kansas, the Miller family—mother Margaret, father Edward, and their 11-year-old daughter Lily—suddenly vanished one night from their old farmhouse.
Authorities found no trace, signs, or evidence of forced entry during their investigation of the area. Shortly after the incident, strange rumors began to spread. Reports emerged of a girl resembling Lily being seen near the farmhouse at night, along with unsettling noises coming from the house.
Michael Wolf, a young journalist working for the town’s local newspaper, decided to investigate the case after hearing these rumors. The claims of a girl resembling Lily appearing around the farmhouse at night compelled him to uncover the truth behind the family's mysterious disappearance. And so, Michael set off toward the abandoned farmhouse.
What happened to Lily? Was she dead, murdered or kidnapped?
The diary entries Lily left behind are eerie and deeply disturbing! Are they a cry for help or demonic vengeance?
Whispers, screams and spooky strange sounds. I wonder what they mean.
Could what's happening on this farm be real? Or is everything an illusion?
Steam data © 2026 Valve Corporation. Trademarks are property of their respective owners.
All matches
Finding similar games…
The StalkedShares Exploration · Walking Simulator · First-Person , adds Linear92% · 341 positive reviews57%Good match—
The Suicide of Rachel FosterShares Exploration · Walking Simulator · First-Person , adds Drama69% · 5k positive reviews56%Good match—
No one lives under the lighthouse Director's cutShares Exploration · Puzzle · Walking Simulator , adds Lovecraftian88% · 2k positive reviews55%Good match—
Someday You'll Return: Director's CutShares Exploration · Puzzle · First-Person , adds Crafting84% · 218 positive reviews55%Good match—
Witch's DollShares Walking Simulator · First-Person · Psychological Horror , adds Cinematic86% · 231 positive reviews55%Good match—
Evil InsideShares First-Person · Psychological Horror · Realistic , adds Experimental65% · 283 positive reviews55%Good match—All matches
The best games like What Happened to Lily? are The Stalked, The Suicide of Rachel Foster, No one lives under the lighthouse Director's cut, Someday You'll Return: Director's Cut, and Witch's Doll.
Match on: filter matches for What Happened to Lily? by tag