62%Good matchShift At Midnight
88%13k88% positive reviews, Very Positive across 13k reviews·Horror · Multiplayer
—







A lonely night shift at a remote gas station turns into a nightmare. Strange customers arrive, unease grows, and the line between reality and hallucination begins to blur.
Pay at the pump
SteamStep into the shoes of a gas station attendant working the graveyard shift. At first, it’s just another quiet night—until unsettling strangers begin to appear one after another. Their presence feels wrong. Their stories don’t add up. And with each encounter, your grip on reality slips further away.

Pay at the Pump is a psychological horror game inspired by the eerie atmosphere of early 2000s survival horror classics. Explore your station, serve suspicious customers, and uncover what lies beneath the surface of a seemingly ordinary night.
🔦 Features:
Will you survive the night—or discover the truth too late?

Steam data © 2026 Valve Corporation. Trademarks are property of their respective owners.
All matches
Finding similar games…
Shift At MidnightShares Psychological Horror · Retro · First-Person , adds Community tag: Online Co-Op88% · 13k positive reviews62%Good match—
Corner Shop: NightshiftShares Psychological Horror · Dark · Realistic , adds Exploration87% · 262 positive reviews58%Good match—
SONG OF HORROR COMPLETE EDITIONShares Psychological Horror · Dark , adds Survival Horror81% · 2k positive reviews57%Good match—
Nightmare FramesShares Psychological Horror · Dark · Retro , adds Point & Click98% · 312 positive reviews56%Good match—
PsychShares Psychological Horror · Dark · Realistic , adds Exploration79% · 293 positive reviews56%Good match—
Graveyard ShiftShares Psychological Horror · Dark · Realistic , adds Exploration75% · 596 positive reviews55%Good match—All matches
The best games like Pay at the pump are Shift At Midnight, Corner Shop: Nightshift, SONG OF HORROR COMPLETE EDITION, Nightmare Frames, and Psych.
Match on: filter matches for Pay at the pump by tag